The art of Gongfu Cha, often referred to as ‘Kung Fu Tea’, transcends the simple act of brewing and drinking tea. Originating in the Fujian and Guangdong provinces of China, Gongfu Cha emphasizes precision, mindfulness, and a deep appreciation for the sensory experiences provided by high-quality tea. This traditional Chinese tea ceremony is characterized by its meticulous method of preparation, which involves multiple short infusions that reveal the intricate flavors and aromas of the tea leaves. The philosophy behind Gongfu Cha focuses on achieving harmony, demonstrating respect, and practicing mindfulness throughout the brewing process. While the practice dates back centuries, it has seamlessly adapted to the modern world, influencing contemporary tea culture globally and fusing traditional techniques with modern innovations. In this exploration, we will delve into the historical background of Gongfu Cha, the philosophical underpinnings of the practice, the essential tools and equipment required, the detailed brewing process, the rich sensory experience it offers, and the ways in which it has evolved in today's bustling, interconnected world. By understanding these facets, we gain a deeper appreciation of Gongfu Cha and its enduring legacy as a cornerstone of tea culture.
1. Historical Background
1.1 Origin of Gongfu Cha
Gongfu Cha (功夫茶), also known as ‘Kung Fu Tea’, originated in the Chinese provinces of Fujian and Guangdong. The term ‘Gongfu’ (功夫) translates to ‘skill’ or ‘effort’, reflecting the meticulous and artful nature of this brewing method. Unlike simpler tea brewing techniques, Gongfu Cha demands a high level of expertise and precision. Although tea drinking in various forms has existed in China for over a millennium, Gongfu Cha specifically began to take shape during the Ming Dynasty (1368–1644) and reached its peak in the Qing Dynasty (1644–1912).
1.2 Evolution from Ming and Qing Dynasties to the Present Day
During the Ming Dynasty, Chinese tea culture underwent significant transformation, notably shifting from powdered tea to loose leaf tea. This period saw the rise of the Yixing teapot, which became essential in brewing Gongfu Cha. The Qing Dynasty further refined this art, emphasizing meticulous rituals and a broader variety of teaware, including the gaiwan and fairness pitcher. Social gatherings centered around Gongfu Cha became more prevalent, embedding the practice into the cultural fabric of Chinese society. In modern times, Gongfu Cha has retained its traditional essence while adapting to contemporary sensibilities. International recognition and technological advancements have made Gongfu Cha more accessible, allowing enthusiasts worldwide to experience this intricate brewing method.
1.3 Cultural and Regional Influences
While Gongfu Cha originated in Fujian and Guangdong, its practice varies regionally, influenced by local tastes and cultural traditions. In Fujian, oolong teas are often used, celebrated for their complex flavors and aromas. Guangdong, particularly the Chaoshan area, is known for its highly detailed tea rituals and specific use of high-fired red clay teapots, which are said to enhance the taste of local teas.
Culturally, Gongfu Cha embodies principles of harmony, respect, and mindfulness. Each step of the brewing process is carried out with precision, reflecting the tea master's skill and dedication. This ritualistic approach transforms tea drinking into a form of meditation and social interaction, making it much more than a mere method of preparation. The aesthetics of Gongfu Cha, from the elegant teaware to the graceful movements, create an immersive sensory experience that is as much about appreciating the tea as it is about connecting with the cultural heritage.
Globally, Gongfu Cha has influenced tea cultures far beyond China, inspiring practices in Japan and the West. It has propelled a renaissance in tea appreciation, encouraging a mindful and sophisticated approach to tea drinking. Workshops, online tutorials, and tea festivals dedicated to Gongfu Cha continue to grow in popularity, spreading its philosophy and techniques to an international audience.
2. The Philosophy of Gongfu Cha
2.1 Meaning of ‘Gongfu’ and Its Application to Tea Brewing
The term ‘Gongfu’ in Gongfu Cha (or Kung Fu Tea) translates to ‘skill’ or ‘effort’ in Chinese. This concept goes beyond physical dexterity to encompass a broader philosophical outlook that applies to tea brewing. Gongfu is about the dedication, patience, and practice required to master the art of tea preparation. It emphasizes the importance of investing time and effort into perfecting each step, from selecting the tea leaves to executing the brewing process with precision. In essence, Gongfu Cha is not just a method of making tea; it is an embodiment of the pursuit of excellence and the deep appreciation for the craft.
2.2 Philosophical Aspects: Mindfulness, Harmony, and Respect
Gongfu Cha intricately weaves together the philosophies of mindfulness, harmony, and respect. At its core, Gongfu Cha is a meditative practice that requires complete focus and presence. Each step is carried out with mindful attention, from the warming of the teapot to the pouring of the tea. This mindfulness transforms the act of brewing tea from a routine task into a moment of contemplation and serenity, allowing the tea master and the participants to connect deeply with the present moment.
Harmony plays a crucial role in Gongfu Cha. The elements of tea, water, teaware, and environment must all be in balance to achieve the perfect brew. This sense of harmony extends beyond the physical components; it envelops the atmosphere, the relationships between the people involved, and their collective experience. The aesthetics of the setup, the fluid movements of the tea master, and the sensory indulgence all contribute to a harmonious experience that transcends the mere act of drinking tea.
Respect is another fundamental principle of Gongfu Cha. This respect is multifaceted: it encompasses respect for the tea leaves, which have been carefully cultivated and processed; respect for the teaware, often crafted by skilled artisans; and respect for the participants, who share in the experience. Each aspect of Gongfu Cha is treated with reverence, highlighting the cultural and historical significance of the practice.
2.3 Comparison with Other Tea Ceremonies Around the World
While Gongfu Cha is unique in its intricacies and philosophy, it shares commonalities with other tea ceremonies around the world, such as the Japanese Chanoyu, Korean Darye, and British afternoon tea. Each of these traditions reflects the cultural values and philosophies of their respective regions.
In Japan, the tea ceremony, or Chanoyu, also emphasizes mindfulness and meticulousness but is more ritualized and codified. Influenced by Zen Buddhism, Chanoyu focuses on the ‘Way of Tea’ (Chado), which encapsulates principles of tranquility, respect, purity, and harmony. The Japanese tea ceremony often uses powdered matcha tea, which is whisked in a bowl, contrasting with the whole leaf teas typically used in Gongfu Cha. Both ceremonies, however, celebrate the unity of the participants with nature and the fleeting beauty of each moment.
Korean Darye, which translates to 'Tea Ritual’, is another practice characterized by simplicity and harmonizing elements. The Korean tea ceremony is less formal than its Japanese counterpart but shares the principles of respect and mindfulness. The focus is on the natural aesthetics and the calming effect of the tea-making process, similar to the harmonious environment fostered in Gongfu Cha.
3. Detailed Description of Essential Tools
To practice Gongfu Cha effectively, several specialized tools and pieces of equipment are required. Each item contributes to the precision, elegance, and sensory delight of this traditional tea ceremony. The essential tools include a Yixing teapot, gaiwan, fairness pitcher, tea pitcher, tea strainer, aroma cups, sipping cups, tea tongs, and tea trays.
3.1 Tools for Gongfu Cha
- Yixing Teapot: The Yixing teapot is highly regarded for its unique properties. Made from purple clay found in Yixing, Jiangsu province, these teapots are known for their ability to enhance the flavor and aroma of the tea. The clay's porous nature allows it to absorb the tea's essence over time, enriching the flavor with each use. Because of this property, it is recommended to dedicate a Yixing teapot to a single type of tea, such as Wuyi Rock Tea (yancha), to avoid cross-contamination of flavors. The small size of the Yixing teapot makes it ideal for the multiple infusions typical in Gongfu Cha.
- Gaiwan: A gaiwan, consisting of a lidded bowl and a saucer, is another versatile brewing vessel. The gaiwan allows the user to control the brewing process more precisely. The lid can be manipulated to strain the tea leaves while pouring, and the wide mouth of the bowl makes it easy to examine the tea leaves' unfolding, color, and aroma. Gaiwans are typically made from porcelain or glass, materials that highlight the tea's visual qualities.
- Fairness Pitcher (Cha Hai): The fairness pitcher, or Cha Hai, is used to ensure that the tea's flavor and strength are consistent for all guests. After brewing, the tea is poured from the gaiwan or teapot into the fairness pitcher before being distributed into individual cups. This ensures that every participant receives tea of equal strength and flavor, embodying the principles of harmony and fairness.
- Tea Pitcher: The tea pitcher holds hot water used for brewing the tea. Typically larger than the teapot, the pitcher is made from heat-resistant materials like ceramic or glass. Maintaining a consistent supply of hot water at the correct temperature is crucial for producing high-quality tea infusions.
- Tea Strainer: The tea strainer is placed over the fairness pitcher to catch any loose leaves or small particles during pouring. This ensures a clean, clear infusion, enhancing the overall drinking experience. Strainers are usually made from fine mesh and come in various designs.
- Aroma Cups (Wen Xiang Bei): Aroma cups, or Wen Xiang Bei, are slender, narrow cups used to appreciate the tea's fragrance. The tea is poured first into the aroma cup and then transferred to the sipping cup (Cha Bei). Smelling the aroma cup allows participants to enjoy the tea's full bouquet before tasting it, heightening the olfactory experience.
- Sipping Cups (Cha Bei): Sipping cups, or Cha Bei, are small cups from which the tea is actually consumed. Their small size allows participants to savor the tea in thoughtful sips, aligning with the Gongfu Cha philosophy of mindfulness and appreciation.
- Tea Tongs: Tea tongs are used to handle the teacups and teaware, ensuring hygienic practices during the ceremony. Typically made from bamboo or wood, the tongs allow the tea master to place and adjust teacups without direct contact.
- Tea Tray (Cha Pan): The tea tray, or Cha Pan, is designed to catch any overflow of water or tea during brewing and serving. These trays often feature a drain or reservoir to manage spills, keeping the tea table clean and organized. They can be made from bamboo, wood, or ceramic and often feature intricate carvings or designs, contributing to the ceremony's visual appeal.
3.2 Importance and Unique Qualities of Each Tool
Each tool in Gongfu Cha serves both a functional and an aesthetic purpose. The Yixing teapot's unique clay composition not only enhances the tea's flavor but also becomes more seasoned and valuable with continued use. The gaiwan allows for granular control over the brewing process, making it possible to adjust infusion times and temperatures. The fairness pitcher ensures that every guest enjoys tea of consistent strength and flavor, promoting the ideals of harmony and fairness central to Gongfu Cha. Aroma cups and sipping cups elevate the sensory experience by engaging the sense of smell and taste more fully. Tea tongs and trays maintain hygiene and organization, essential for a seamless and aesthetically pleasing tea ceremony.
3.3 Selection of High-Quality Tea Leaves and Water
The quality of tea leaves and water is paramount in Gongfu Cha. High-quality tea leaves should be whole and intact, preferably hand-picked and processed with care to preserve their natural oils and flavors. For instance, high-quality Wuyi rock tea (yancha) is known for its rich, complex flavor profile, which can be fully appreciated through the Gongfu Cha method. Proper storage of tea leaves in a cool, dry place away from strong odors is also essential to maintain their freshness.
Equally important is the selection of water. Ideally, spring water or filtered water is used to avoid impurities that can affect the tea's taste. The water should have a neutral pH and balanced mineral content to complement the tea's natural flavors. The temperature of the water is also crucial, typically ranging from 90°C to 100°C (194°F to 212°F), depending on the type of tea being brewed. Consistent water temperature ensures that the tea leaves release their flavors evenly with each infusion.
In conclusion, the tools and equipment used in Gongfu Cha are meticulously designed to enhance both the functional and sensory aspects of the tea ceremony. From the Yixing teapot's unique clay properties to the gaiwan's versatility, each tool contributes to a mindful, harmonious, and respectful tea experience. Complemented by high-quality tea leaves and water, these elements come together to create an artful and enriching practice that continues to captivate tea enthusiasts around the world.
4. The Process of Brewing Gongfu Cha
Brewing Gongfu Cha is an art form that emphasizes precision, mindfulness, and engagement with the senses. Each step in the process is essential for bringing out the best qualities of the tea. From preparation to the multiple infusion process, mastering Gongfu Cha involves techniques and tips that ensure a perfect brew. Here’s a closer look at the intricate steps and considerations involved.
4.1 Preparation Steps
Warming the Teapot and Cups:The first step in the Gongfu Cha process is to warm the teapot, gaiwan (lidded bowl), and cups. This is typically done by rinsing them with hot water. Warming the utensils helps maintain a consistent temperature during brewing, which is essential for extracting the tea's full flavor and aroma. This step also cleanses the teaware, ensuring that no residual smells or tastes interfere with the tea.
Measuring Tea Leaves:Precision in measuring the tea leaves is crucial for achieving the desired taste. The amount of tea used can vary depending on the type of tea and personal preference, but a common guideline is to use about 5-7 grams of tea leaves per 100ml of water. The leaves should be whole and intact, as broken leaves can affect the quality and clarity of the brew. Handling the leaves gently also preserves their delicate structure and essential oils.
4.2 The Multiple Infusion Process
Gongfu Cha is distinguished by its practice of multiple infusions, allowing for a more nuanced exploration of the tea's flavor profile. Each infusion typically lasts only seconds to a couple of minutes, depending on the type of tea.
- First Infusion:The first infusion is often a quick rinse that awakens the tea leaves and removes any dust or impurities. This rinse water is usually discarded.
- Subsequent Infusions:The following infusions are where the real tasting begins. Each infusion reveals different layers of flavors and aromas:
- Second Infusion: This is generally the most flavorful, as the leaves have fully opened. It typically lasts between 10 to 20 seconds.
- Third to Fifth Infusions: These continue to offer robust flavors, but each subsequent infusion will require slightly longer steeping times to maintain the intensity of the flavor.
- Sixth Infusion and Beyond: Depending on the quality of the leaves, many teas can provide 10 or more infusions. Each later infusion may reveal subtler, softer flavors that are often the most appreciated by tea enthusiasts.
4.3 Techniques and Tips for Achieving the Perfect Brew
Achieving the perfect brew in Gongfu Cha involves several techniques that optimize the extraction of flavor from the tea leaves.
Controlled Pouring:Pouring water in a controlled, circular motion ensures that the tea leaves are evenly submerged and agitated. This helps in uniform extraction and prevents the leaves from clumping together. The use of a fairness pitcher (Cha Hai) to distribute the brewed tea into cups also ensures that each cup has a consistent flavor.
Proper Timing:Timing is critical. Using a timer or counting silently can help maintain consistency. Over-steeping or under-steeping can drastically alter the taste, making timing one of the most crucial elements.
Water Quality:Using spring water or filtered water with a neutral pH balance is essential, as tap water can contain minerals and chemicals that affect the flavor. The water should be freshly boiled and allowed to cool slightly to the desired temperature range.
4.4 Role of Temperature and Timing
The temperature of the water and steeping time play vital roles in the Gongfu Cha process.
4.4.1 Temperature
Different types of tea require specific temperature ranges:
- Green Tea and Yellow Tea: 75°C to 85°C (167°F to 185°F)
- White Tea: 80°C to 90°C (176°F to 194°F) (90°C to 100°C for Aged White Tea)
- Oolong Tea: 90°C to 100°C (194°F to 212°F)
- Black Tea: 90°C to 100°C (194°F to 212°F)
- Pu-erh Tea: 95°C to 100°C (203°F to 212°F)
Using too hot water can scorch the leaves, resulting in bitterness, while too cool water can under-extract the flavors.
4.4.2 Timing
Steeping times should start short (10-20 seconds) and increase gradually with each subsequent infusion. This method ensures that the tea's flavors are extracted gradually, allowing for multiple infusions that each offer distinct flavors. A balance between temperature and timing ensures that the tea leaves release their optimal flavors without becoming astringent.
5. Sensory Experience
The practice of Gongfu Cha transcends mere tea consumption, offering a rich, multifaceted sensory experience that engages taste, aroma, and appearance. This holistic approach not only amplifies the pleasure of drinking tea but also cultivates a deeper appreciation and mindfulness. By fully engaging with each sensory aspect, Gongfu Cha transforms tea drinking into an art form.
5.1 Exploration of the Sensory Dimensions
Taste:The taste of tea brewed through Gongfu Cha is distinguished by its depth and complexity. With multiple infusions, each successive brew reveals different layers of flavor. For example, a high-quality oolong like Wuyi rock tea (yancha) can exhibit a spectrum of tastes ranging from floral and fruity to nutty and roasted, all within a single session. The short, controlled infusions ensure that the tea’s bitterness is minimized, allowing its natural sweetness and nuanced flavors to unfold gradually.
Aroma: Aroma is a critical component of the Gongfu Cha experience. The initial smell of the dry leaves sets the stage, offering hints of what’s to come. As hot water meets the leaves, the aroma evolves, filling the air with a bouquet of scents. The use of aroma cups (Wen Xiang Bei) adds another layer to this olfactory enjoyment. After transferring the tea from the aroma cup to the sipping cup, one can savor the lingering fragrance within the aroma cup, appreciating the tea's full aromatic profile before taking a sip.
Appearance: Visual appreciation is also integral to Gongfu Cha. The appearance of the dry leaves, the color of the brewed tea, and the gradual unfurling of the leaves during steeping are all part of this sensory adventure. High-quality teas often have whole, unbroken leaves that unfold gracefully when steeped. The tea liquor, ranging in color from pale gold to deep amber, indicates the strength and character of the brew. Glass gaiwans or teapots can enhance this visual enjoyment by allowing a clear view of the leaves as they reveal their beauty.
5.2 How Gongfu Cha Enhances the Appreciation of Tea
Gongfu Cha enhances tea appreciation by demanding a high level of engagement from the tea drinker. The meticulous brewing process encourages not just consumption, but active participation and observation. Multiple short infusions allow for a detailed exploration of the tea’s characteristics, with each round offering new flavors and aromas. This contrasts with Western brewing methods, which often result in a single, less nuanced cup.
Additionally, the ceremonial aspects of Gongfu Cha—such as warming the teapot and cups, carefully measuring the tea, and timing the infusions—create a sense of ritual that elevates the entire experience. It becomes more than just drinking tea; it becomes a meditative practice that fosters mindfulness and presence.
5.3 Techniques for Mindful Tasting
Engage All Senses:Mindful tasting in Gongfu Cha involves engaging all the senses. Begin by appreciating the visual aspects of the dry leaves, observing their color, shape, and texture. As the tea brews, inhale deeply to capture the evolving aroma, which tempts your palate with a preview of the flavors to come.
Savor Slowly: When it comes to tasting the tea, take small, deliberate sips to allow the liquid to cover your palate fully. Notice the initial flavors and how they change as the tea moves from the front to the back of your mouth. Pay attention to the aftertaste, which can linger, offering additional layers of flavor that emerge after you have swallowed the tea.
Focus on Temperature and Texture: Notice the temperature and texture of the tea. Some teas may feel velvety smooth, while others have a more astringent quality. The temperature can also influence the taste, with cooler sips highlighting different aspects of the flavor profile compared to warmer ones.
Reflect Between Infusions: After each infusion, take a moment to reflect on the experience. Consider how the flavor, aroma, and appearance have evolved with each steeping. This reflection not only enhances your appreciation of the tea but also makes each session a unique journey.
Practice Patience: Finally, practice patience. Gongfu Cha is a slow and deliberate process that rewards those who take the time to engage fully with each step. This patience not only leads to a more enjoyable tea experience but also cultivates a sense of tranquility and mindfulness that extends beyond the tea table.
6. Modern Adaptations and Practices
The ancient art of Gongfu Cha has gracefully evolved to fit into the tapestry of modern life, continuing to enchant tea enthusiasts around the world. While the core principles of Gongfu Cha remain unchanged, contemporary practices have introduced various adaptations and innovations, reflecting the influence of globalization and technological advancements.
6.1 How Gongfu Cha is Practiced Today
In today's fast-paced world, Gongfu Cha serves as both a meditative practice and a social ritual. Tea enthusiasts, whether experienced or novice, often gather in tea houses or homes to practice Gongfu Cha, savoring the meticulous process of brewing and enjoying multiple infusions of high-quality tea. The practice provides a respite from the daily grind, allowing individuals to slow down and appreciate the art of tea making.
The essential steps remain the same: warming the teaware, carefully measuring the tea leaves, and conducting multiple short infusions to extract the tea's full flavor profile. However, today's practitioners are more flexible, often merging traditional methods with personal preferences and modern conveniences. For example, some may use electric kettles with precise temperature settings to achieve the ideal water temperature with ease.
6.2 Influence on Contemporary Tea Culture
Gongfu Cha has had a significant impact on contemporary tea culture, not only in China but globally. The meticulous approach to tea brewing has inspired a renewed appreciation for the quality, craftsmanship, and complexity of tea. This renaissance has led to a surge in specialty tea shops, tea festivals, and workshops that focus on educating people about traditional Gongfu Cha techniques and the intricate characteristics of different tea varieties.
In the digital age, social media platforms and online communities have become valuable resources for sharing knowledge and fostering a global tea culture. Tea enthusiasts around the world connect through blogs, YouTube channels, and social media groups, exchanging tips, techniques, and experiences. This has democratized access to information about Gongfu Cha, making it more accessible to a wider audience.
6.3 Fusion of Traditional Techniques with Modern Innovations
The fusion of traditional Gongfu Cha techniques with modern innovations has created a dynamic and exciting tea culture. Here are a few ways in which this fusion manifests:
Teaware Design: Contemporary teaware designers blend traditional aesthetics with modern functionality. For example, double-walled glass teapots preserve the classic look of a gaiwan while offering better heat retention and a clearer view of the tea leaves unfurling.
Technological Aids: Precise temperature control is crucial for Gongfu Cha, and modern innovations like electric kettles with adjustable settings have made it easier to achieve the ideal brew. Additionally, smart timers and apps help practitioners keep track of steeping times, ensuring consistent results.
Global Influence: Gongfu Cha has inspired variations and adaptations in different cultures. In the West, for instance, some tea enthusiasts have started to incorporate elements of Gongfu Cha into their own tea traditions, experimenting with different types of tea and brewing methods. This cross-cultural exchange enriches the global tea scene, introducing new flavors and techniques.
Sustainability Practices: Modern tea practitioners are increasingly conscious of sustainability. This includes sourcing ethically grown tea leaves, using biodegradable teabags, and choosing eco-friendly teaware materials. These practices harmonize traditional respect for nature with contemporary environmental concerns.
7. Conclusion
In conclusion, Gongfu Cha stands as a testament to the timeless allure and intricate beauty of traditional Chinese tea ceremonies. From its origins in the Fujian and Guangdong provinces to its refinement during the Ming and Qing Dynasties, Gongfu Cha has perpetuated a legacy of mindfulness, harmony, and respect. The practice has not only preserved its historical essence but has also embraced modern adaptations, making it relevant in today’s fast-paced world. The meticulous brewing process, with its emphasis on sensory exploration through taste, aroma, and appearance, enhances the appreciation of tea, transforming each session into an immersive and meditative experience. By utilizing specialized tools and adhering to precise techniques, practitioners can achieve the perfect brew that captures the multifaceted flavors of high-quality tea leaves. Moreover, the global influence of Gongfu Cha has fostered a renewed interest in the art of tea, encouraging a mindful and sophisticated approach to tea drinking. As Gongfu Cha continues to evolve, it remains a poignant reminder of the depth and richness of tea culture, inviting enthusiasts worldwide to slow down, savor, and connect with the enduring tradition of mindful tea preparation.
See Also:
The Six Major Teas of China: What You Should Know as a Beginner
The Typology of Aroma and Flavor in Tea
Reference
Ahmed, Selena, et al. "Pu-Erh Tea Tasting in Yunnan, China: Correlation of Drinkers’ Perceptions to Phytochemistry." Journal of Ethnopharmacology, vol. 132, no. 1, 2010, pp. 176–185. DOI: 10.1016/j.jep.2010.08.016
Chen, Yu. "Kung Fu Tea: A Comparative Study of Ritualistic Tea Brewing Techniques." Asian Material Culture Studies, vol. 7, no. 1, 2018, pp. 89–104. DOI: 10.2979/asiamaterculturestud.7.1.89
Hong, B., & Ma, M.Y. (2020). A Study on Tea Drinking Experience Factors of Kong Fu Tea in Southern Fujian Province of China. In S. Fukuda (Ed.), Advances in Affective and Pleasurable Design. AHFE 2019. Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, vol 952. Springer, Cham. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-20441-9_43
d'Abbs, Peter H. N. "Art as Everyday Practice: A Study of Gongfu Tea in Chaoshan, China." Master's thesis, University of New England, 2017. https://rune.une.edu.au/web/bitstream/1959.11/23092/5/open/SOURCE03.pdf.
d'Abbs, Peter H. N. "Tea Art as Everyday Practice: Gongfu Tea in Chaoshan, Guangdong, Today." Asian Studies Review 43, no. 3 (2019): 475–492. https://doi.org/10.1080/14442213.2019.1611908